Project Management Tools Compared: MS Project, Jira, Azure DevOps, Asana, Smartsheet and Spreadsheets
Walk into any project office and you will find a different set of tools: one team lives in Microsoft Project, another in Jira, a third in a shared spreadsheet. No tool manages a project for you, but the right one makes planning, tracking and reporting far easier, and the wrong one adds friction. This lesson compares popular categories and products, and gives you a method for choosing. Features and pricing change often, so check each vendor’s current documentation before deciding.
What Do You Need a Tool For?
Before comparing products, list the jobs you need done:
- Planning and scheduling: work breakdown, dependencies, Gantt charts, critical path, baselines.
- Task and backlog management: boards, sprints, workflows, assignments.
- Resource and capacity management: who is available, overallocation, timesheets.
- Budget and cost tracking: forecasts, actuals, earned value.
- Risk, issue and change logs: RAID tracking and approvals.
- Collaboration and documentation: comments, files, wikis, notifications.
- Reporting and dashboards: status views for different audiences.
- Portfolio view: roll-up across many projects.
- Integration: with source control, build pipelines, chat, calendars and finance.
Categories of Tool
Traditional scheduling tools
Strong at detailed schedules with dependencies, critical path, baselines and resource leveling. Best for predictive projects and complex plans. Microsoft Project is the best-known example.
Agile work management tools
Built around backlogs, boards, sprints, workflows and engineering integrations. Best for software teams using Scrum or Kanban. Jira and Azure DevOps are widely used examples; see Jira for Scrum Masters.
General work and collaboration platforms
Flexible, visual tools that combine lists, boards, timelines and calendars. Easy to adopt across business teams. Asana, Trello, monday.com, ClickUp and similar products belong here.
Spreadsheet-style project tools
Smartsheet and similar products offer familiar grids with Gantt views, automation and dashboards, which is attractive to teams used to spreadsheets.
Spreadsheets and documents
Excel or Google Sheets remain surprisingly common for risk logs, budgets and simple trackers. They are cheap and flexible, but weak on dependencies, version control and collaboration at scale.
Portfolio and resource management suites
Enterprise platforms for managing demand, capacity and investment across a portfolio, usually adopted with a PMO.
Comparison at a Glance
| Tool type / example | Strongest at | Typical weakness | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft Project | Detailed scheduling, critical path, baselines, resource leveling | Steeper learning curve; less natural for Agile boards | Predictive and complex plans, construction-style IT programmes |
| Jira | Backlogs, sprints, workflows, reporting, software integrations | Can become complex; weaker for non-software work without configuration | Software and Agile teams |
| Azure DevOps | Boards plus repositories, pipelines and testing in one suite | Best value when you use the wider Microsoft ecosystem | Engineering teams on Microsoft tooling |
| Asana / monday.com / ClickUp | Ease of use, flexible views, cross-functional collaboration | Less depth for formal scheduling, EVM or compliance | Business and mixed teams, marketing and operations projects |
| Trello | Simple Kanban boards | Limited reporting and dependency handling | Small teams and simple workflows |
| Smartsheet | Spreadsheet familiarity with Gantt, forms and automation | Can get unwieldy with very large, complex projects | Business teams moving from spreadsheets |
| Excel / Google Sheets | Flexibility, low cost, universal skills | Manual updates; poor collaboration and dependency logic | Logs, budgets, small projects |
How to Choose a Tool
- Start with your process, not the product. Define how you plan, track, report and govern work. A tool will not repair a weak process.
- Match your methodology. Predictive projects need dependencies and baselines; Agile teams need backlogs and boards; hybrid teams may need both views.
- Consider your users. Include developers, business users, executives and external partners. A tool people dislike will not be updated.
- Check reporting needs. What does the sponsor need to see, and can the tool produce it without hours of manual work?
- Review integration. Connection to source control, CI/CD, chat, calendars and finance systems saves effort and avoids duplicated data.
- Check scalability and governance. Permissions, audit trails, security and data residency matter in larger or regulated organisations.
- Run a pilot. Try two or three candidates on a real small project before committing.
- Count the full cost: licences, configuration, training, administration and migration.
- Look at support and community. Good documentation and active user communities shorten the learning curve.
Example Scenarios
A 12-person software team using Scrum. A backlog and sprint tool such as Jira or Azure DevOps fits, with a lightweight roadmap view for stakeholders.
A data centre migration with hundreds of dependent tasks. A scheduling tool with critical path and baseline tracking is more appropriate, supported by a RAID log.
An HR system rollout involving HR, IT and finance teams. A flexible collaboration platform with a timeline view, a shared risk log and a simple dashboard may suit a mixed audience better than an engineering tool.
A small internal improvement project. A shared Kanban board or even a spreadsheet may be enough.
Tools for Specific Artefacts
- Schedules: Gantt features in scheduling tools; see Project Scheduling and the Critical Path.
- Risks and issues: a shared log with owners and dates; see RAID Logs, Issues and Dependencies.
- Documents and decisions: a wiki or shared drive with version control.
- Communication: team chat and video, with agreed rules so decisions are recorded elsewhere.
- Diagrams: whiteboard and diagramming tools for architecture, process maps and dependency maps.
Reporting and Dashboards
A tool is only as useful as its data. Keep information current by making updates part of the team’s routine (for example, at stand-up or before the weekly review) and limit the number of mandatory fields so updating takes minutes. Build one or two dashboards with the key measures: progress against plan, top risks and issues, budget forecast and upcoming milestones. See Project Communication Management.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing a tool because it is popular instead of because it fits your process.
- Over-configuring workflows with so many fields and statuses that nobody updates them.
- Using several tools without deciding which one is the source of truth.
- Skipping training and expecting adoption.
- Producing beautiful dashboards from stale data.
- Define the jobs to be done, then match tools to methodology, users and reporting needs.
- Scheduling tools suit predictive plans; Agile tools suit backlogs and sprints; collaboration tools suit mixed teams; spreadsheets suit simple logs.
- Pilot before committing, and count the full cost including training and administration.
- Name one source of truth and keep it current.