Handling Underperforming Scrum Teams: A Scrum Master’s Approach

When a Scrum Team is struggling, the Scrum Master's first responsibility is to understand the situation rather than immediately blame individuals.

Poor results can come from many causes, including unclear goals, impediments, dependencies, weak collaboration or ineffective ways of working.

What Does Underperformance Mean?

A team may be struggling when problems repeatedly affect its ability to create value or achieve its goals.

Possible signs include:

  • Sprint Goals are frequently missed.
  • Work remains unfinished across multiple Sprints.
  • Impediments remain unresolved.
  • Team collaboration is weak.
  • Quality problems repeatedly occur.
  • The same problems appear in every Retrospective.

Don't Start With Blame

Poor performance does not automatically mean that individual team members are performing badly.

The Scrum Master should help identify what is actually preventing the team from being effective.

Instead of asking:

"Who is causing the problem?"

Ask:

"What is preventing the team from being effective?"

1. Look for the Root Cause

The visible problem may only be a symptom.

Problem:

Work repeatedly remains unfinished at the end of the Sprint.

Possible causes:
  • Product Backlog Items are too large.
  • Too much work is started.
  • External dependencies create delays.
  • Testing happens too late.
  • The team lacks required knowledge.

2. Make Problems Visible

Transparency helps the team understand patterns instead of relying on assumptions.

The Scrum Master can help the team inspect:

  • Blocked work.
  • Recurring impediments.
  • Workflow problems.
  • Quality issues.
  • Missed Sprint Goals.

3. Use the Sprint Retrospective

The Sprint Retrospective is an important opportunity to inspect how the team worked and identify improvements.

Focus on a small number of meaningful improvements rather than creating a long list of actions.

4. Encourage Small Experiments

Teams do not need to redesign their entire way of working at once.

Problem Too much work is started.
Experiment Finish existing work before starting more.
Observe Check whether work flows more smoothly.
Adapt Keep, change or stop the experiment.

5. Address Impediments

Some performance problems may be outside the team's direct control.

The Scrum Master should help address organizational impediments such as:

  • Slow approvals.
  • External dependencies.
  • Unavailable environments.
  • Unnecessary processes.
  • Poor communication between teams.

6. Improve Collaboration

A team may struggle when people work independently instead of working toward a shared Sprint Goal.

Encourage knowledge sharing, communication and collective ownership of team outcomes.

7. Coach Instead of Taking Control

The Scrum Master should resist the temptation to start assigning tasks or making every decision.

Taking control may create short-term movement but can weaken self-management.

Remember:

The objective is not to make the team dependent on the Scrum Master. The objective is to improve the team's ability to solve problems itself.

When Individual Problems Exist

Sometimes a genuine individual performance or behavior problem may exist.

The Scrum Master can help make its impact transparent and facilitate appropriate conversations.

Formal employee performance management, however, normally belongs to the appropriate manager or organizational process.

Common Scrum Master Mistakes

Blaming Individuals Assuming one person is responsible for every team problem.
Taking Control Starting to assign and manage individual tasks.
Chasing Metrics Trying to improve numbers without understanding the cause.
Ignoring Recurring Problems Discussing the same issue repeatedly without taking action.

Useful Questions

Problem "What is repeatedly going wrong?"
Cause "What might be causing it?"
Experiment "What could we try differently?"
Learning "How will we know whether it helped?"

Key Takeaway

When a Scrum Team is struggling, focus on understanding the system, team dynamics and root causes rather than immediately blaming individuals.

The Scrum Master helps create transparency, remove impediments, encourage improvement and strengthen the team's ability to solve its own problems.